MyVideoGameList/myvideogamelist.com
MyVideoGameList/myvideogamelist.com
3
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 45 Pull requests Projects 3 Releases Activity Actions

Recent gamer updates should include comment activity #346

New issue
Closed
opened 2026-06-01 21:01:49 -05:00 by Codex · 1 comment
Codex commented 2026-06-01 21:01:49 -05:00
Member
Copy link

Summary

Comments posted on the site are not showing up in the Recent Gamer Updates feed.

Source: https://www.notion.so/3702f7baaae480ef9e0aefd43923c3a6

Reported behavior

The Notion report says: "When commenting anywhere on the website it doesn't show up in the recent gamer updates feed."

The intended comment surfaces called out for this issue are:

  • User profile comments
  • Blog entry comments
  • Game profile comments

Repo context

  • The Recent Gamer Updates page is served by App\Http\Controllers\RecentGamerUpdateController.
  • Recent feed items are fetched and formatted by App\Support\RecentGamerUpdates.
  • App\Support\RecentGamerUpdates already has a game_comment_created message branch, but the comment creation controllers should be verified to ensure the expected gamer_updates activity is actually recorded.
  • Relevant comment store endpoints are handled by GameCommentController, BlogCommentController, and ProfileCommentController.

Acceptance criteria

  • Posting a game profile comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item.
  • Posting a blog entry comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item.
  • Posting a user profile comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item.
  • Feed items identify the commenting user and link to the relevant target page when possible.
  • Existing privacy, banned/deleted user, and hide_public_feed_entries filtering still applies.
  • Deleted comments should not leave misleading public feed entries, or the expected deletion behavior should be explicitly handled.

Test coverage

  • Add or update feature tests for game, blog, and profile comment posting that assert the Recent Gamer Updates feed includes the new comment activity.
  • Cover hidden/banned/deleted users or private content where relevant so comments that should not be public do not leak into the feed.
  • Run the affected tests with php artisan test --compact.
## Summary Comments posted on the site are not showing up in the Recent Gamer Updates feed. Source: https://www.notion.so/3702f7baaae480ef9e0aefd43923c3a6 ## Reported behavior The Notion report says: "When commenting anywhere on the website it doesn't show up in the recent gamer updates feed." The intended comment surfaces called out for this issue are: - User profile comments - Blog entry comments - Game profile comments ## Repo context - The Recent Gamer Updates page is served by `App\Http\Controllers\RecentGamerUpdateController`. - Recent feed items are fetched and formatted by `App\Support\RecentGamerUpdates`. - `App\Support\RecentGamerUpdates` already has a `game_comment_created` message branch, but the comment creation controllers should be verified to ensure the expected `gamer_updates` activity is actually recorded. - Relevant comment store endpoints are handled by `GameCommentController`, `BlogCommentController`, and `ProfileCommentController`. ## Acceptance criteria - [x] Posting a game profile comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item. - [x] Posting a blog entry comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item. - [x] Posting a user profile comment creates a Recent Gamer Updates feed item. - [x] Feed items identify the commenting user and link to the relevant target page when possible. - [x] Existing privacy, banned/deleted user, and `hide_public_feed_entries` filtering still applies. - [x] Deleted comments should not leave misleading public feed entries, or the expected deletion behavior should be explicitly handled. ## Test coverage - [x] Add or update feature tests for game, blog, and profile comment posting that assert the Recent Gamer Updates feed includes the new comment activity. - [x] Cover hidden/banned/deleted users or private content where relevant so comments that should not be public do not leak into the feed. - [x] Run the affected tests with `php artisan test --compact`.
jimmyb self-assigned this 2026-06-03 19:27:33 -05:00
Codex commented 2026-06-03 20:52:16 -05:00
Author
Member
Copy link

Implemented in b5f4a34 (Add comment activity to recent gamer updates).

Notes:

  • Game, blog, and profile comment store flows now write gamer_updates activity rows with the comment as the performed-on subject.
  • Public blog comment feed activity is only logged for published public blog entries, so private/friends-only/draft entries do not leak through Recent Gamer Updates.
  • Recent Gamer Updates now renders blog/profile comment targets with links and filters soft-deleted comment subjects so deleted comments do not leave misleading public feed rows.
  • During push, origin/dev had moved with favorite/wishlist Recent Gamer Updates work, so this commit was rebased and the conflict was resolved by preserving both the remote favorite/wishlist variants and this issue's comment variants.

Verification:

  • vendor/bin/pint ... --format agent
  • php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/GameProfileTest.php --filter="authenticated users can post game comments and guests cannot"
  • php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/BlogTest.php
  • php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/UserProfileTest.php
  • php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/RecentGamerUpdatesPageTest.php
Implemented in `b5f4a34` (`Add comment activity to recent gamer updates`). Notes: - Game, blog, and profile comment store flows now write `gamer_updates` activity rows with the comment as the performed-on subject. - Public blog comment feed activity is only logged for published public blog entries, so private/friends-only/draft entries do not leak through Recent Gamer Updates. - Recent Gamer Updates now renders blog/profile comment targets with links and filters soft-deleted comment subjects so deleted comments do not leave misleading public feed rows. - During push, `origin/dev` had moved with favorite/wishlist Recent Gamer Updates work, so this commit was rebased and the conflict was resolved by preserving both the remote favorite/wishlist variants and this issue's comment variants. Verification: - `vendor/bin/pint ... --format agent` - `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/GameProfileTest.php --filter="authenticated users can post game comments and guests cannot"` - `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/BlogTest.php` - `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/UserProfileTest.php` - `php artisan test --compact tests/Feature/RecentGamerUpdatesPageTest.php`
Codex 2026-06-03 20:54:30 -05:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag specified
Branches Tags
master
dev
No results found.
Labels
Clear labels   
automated

   
code-quality

   
component: admin dashboard
The issue is related to the admin dashboard functionality.

  
component: backend
The issue is related to the backend code.

  
component: billing
The issue is related to our billing and payment system functionality.

  
component: content management
The issue is related to site content and moderation functionality.

  
component: faqs
The issue relates to our frequency asked questions and their categories.

  
component: game genres
The issue is related to genres in relation to games.

  
component: game lists
The issue is related to user-facing game list functionality.

  
component: game reviews
The issue relates to the game reviews functionality.

  
component: game search
The issue is related to the user-facing game search functionality.

  
component: games
The issue relates to games in our database.

  
component: internal notifications
The issue is related to the functionality of notifications sent for internal usage.

  
component: platforms
The issue is related to platform functionality.

  
component: security
The issue relates to the security issues within the app.

  
component: tests
The issue relates to unit and feature tests.

  
component: user api
The issue relates to the user-facing API.

  
component: user badges
The issue is related to our badge/achievements functionality.

  
component: user blogs
The issue is related to blogging functionality.

  
component: user consoles
The issue is related to user console lists functionality.

  
component: user favorites
This is issue is related to the favorites functionality.

  
component: user friends
The issue relates to the friending functionality.

  
component: user notifications
The issue is related to user-facing notifications functionality.

  
component: user profiles
The issue is related to user profile functionality.

  
component: user site notifications
The issue relates to the functionality of notifications shown to users directly on the website.

  
component: user wishlists
This issue is related to the wishlists functionality.

  
component: web design
This issue is related to the design of the website.

  
dependencies
Pull requests that update a dependency file.

  
php
Pull requests that update PHP code.

  
priority
high
 The issue is considered a high priority.

  
priority
low
 This issue is considered a low priority.

  
priority
medium
 This issue is considered a medium priority.

  
security-hotspot

   
source: codex

   
source: sonarqube
  
status
awaiting feedback
 The issue is awaiting feedback from others.

  
status
backlog
 Issues that are in a backlog status.

  
status
done
 The issue has been completed and closed out.

  
status
in progress
 The issue is in progress and being actively worked on.

  
status
in queue
 The issue is in queue and will be worked on shortly.

  
status
in review
 The issue work has been completed and now the work needs to be reviewed.

  
status
needs codex review
 Use this tag to have Codex spiffy up your issue.

  
status
needs investigation
 The issue describes a problem which needs further investigation.

  
status
wontfix
 This issue will not be worked on.

  
type: bug
The issue describes something working the way it wasn't intended too.

  
type: documentation
Improvements or additions to site documentation.

  
type: feature
A new feature for the website.

  
type: improvement
An improvement on an existing feature.

  
type: regression
The issue describes a function that previously worked and no longer does.

  
type: task
A small-ish task.

No labels
automated
code-quality
component: admin dashboard
component: backend
component: billing
component: content management
component: faqs
component: game genres
component: game lists
component: game reviews
component: game search
component: games
component: internal notifications
component: platforms
component: security
component: tests
component: user api
component: user badges
component: user blogs
component: user consoles
component: user favorites
component: user friends
component: user notifications
component: user profiles
component: user site notifications
component: user wishlists
component: web design
dependencies
php
priority
high
priority
low
priority
medium
security-hotspot
source: codex
source: sonarqube
status
awaiting feedback
status
backlog
status
done
status
in progress
status
in queue
status
in review
status
needs codex review
status
needs investigation
status
wontfix
type: bug
type: documentation
type: feature
type: improvement
type: regression
type: task
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Laravel 13 + TailwindCSS
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
jimmyb
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
MyVideoGameList/myvideogamelist.com#346
No description provided.